How To Get Away With Murder

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

My review
How To Get Away With Murder is an impressive debut from Rebecca Philipson, built around a clever and compelling premise that offers a fresh spin on the detective genre. I’ve always liked a book-within-a-book structure, and this novel makes effective use of that device. I’ll also say upfront that didn’t see the final twist coming!

DI Sam Hansen is on leave after being assaulted by a fellow officer, an experience that led to a breakdown. Although her therapist encourages a gradual return to work, Sam resists the idea until she unexpectedly stumbles upon a crime scene while heading home from an appointment. Fourteen-year-old Charlotte has been found dead, and Sam immediately decides to return to work and help solve the case. The investigation centers on a suspected serial killer who has written a how-to manual under the pseudonym Denver Brady. A copy of the book is found at Charlotte’s murder scene. The central question becomes whether Charlotte was killed by Denver or by a copycat inspired by the book.

Philipson weaves in contemporary cultural references that help ground the story in a modern setting and contribute to character development. Unfortunately, some of these references, particularly those tied to Sam, felt questionable or awkwardly handled. While Sam is clearly well developed on the page, I struggled to connect with her, largely due to her rapid personality shifts and what felt like forced or ill-fitting cultural touchstones. At times, her decisions came across as unnecessary or implausible stretches.

I do have two main criticisms. First, the writing felt a bit clunky in places, and some of the social commentary, especially as it relates to Sam, didn’t always land for me. Second, while I enjoyed the Denver Brady chapters, I think they would have benefited from being slightly shorter. These chapters were fascinating and important to the plot, but at times they dragged, interrupting the overall pacing.

How To Get Away With Murder is a strong debut with an inventive premise and a genuinely surprising ending. I’d cautiously recommend it to readers who enjoy accessible police procedurals with unexpected twists. Philipson shows a great deal of promise, and I’m interested to see what she does next.

Many thanks to NetGalley, Minotaur Books, and Rebecca Philipson for an advance copy in exchange for my honest review.

My recommendation: cautiously recommend. Solid novel from a debut writer!

I look forward to your comments! Note that comments are moderated and you will get a notification when they are approved.